Welcome to Hot Tub University!

Costco Hot Tub Review

A detailed review of Costco Hot Tubs


For years now mass merchants have been trying, unsuccessfully, to break into the hot tub market with promises of great prices on good quality Hot Tubs and Swim Spas. The reality is they have failed miserably to provide quality products at a competitive price, instead selling low end spas at prices that any budget online direct seller can meet or beat.


Click For Our Video!

Costco Hot Tub Review
video

So why is it that these retail giants fail again and again with this product? Why are Costco Hot Tubs such a problem? Why do they never get it right? And why, when they do finally get a good quality product like the Canadian Costco Hot Tub from Beachcomber is their price so high???

In our 2021 Costco Hot Tub review, we look at the multitude of reasons why you really want to do your homework before purchasing a Costco Hot Tub, and why the internet is awash with complaints, stories of abysmal service and nightmare stories about Costco Hot Tubs.

The reality is that mass merchants like Costco suck at complex products such as hot tubs for a myriad of reasons including lack of knowledge, lack of available information to consumers, lack of volume of sales and their insistence at being the cheapest without understanding what makes a good hot tub... leaving them in the unenviable position of selling utter rubbish at prices that any local dealer could meet or beat if they were willing to sell such a low level of quality.

So let's look in depth at the reasons they keep failing their customers on this product and then let's have a look at some actual models and see how they stack up against quality hot tubs.

  1. The first reason they tend to fail at these products is because they simply do not do the volume of sales to get good pricing from suppliers. That's right Costco doesn't really sell that many hot tubs, in fact, there are individual dealers that sell more hot tubs in a year than the entire Costco Hot Tub sales across the country!
  2. The second reason Costco Hot Tubs review badly is they try to sell too cheaply to get the best price for their members. The problem here,is that it's impossible to supply them with a good quality product because of the pricing they try and sell at, so they can beat the cheap internet hot tubs but they just don't seem to grasp that these tubs are fundamentally different than the quality hot tubs. In order to supply Costco Hot Tubs you need to cut so many corners on the build quality to get the price point right that you can't possibly build a reliable spa. The shells are thin, the fabrication is low end, the insulation is inexpensive, low R-value, and the parts are a mix of good and bad. The only exception I have ever seen is the Canadian Costco stores selling a Beachcomber hot tub, and in this case it's not a bad hot tub but it's also not a good price!!! You can easily buy the same or better quality hot tub with more features for less money!
  3. The third reason why Costco Hot Tubs are a mess is they have a history of bankrupting hot tub suppliers because of the massive return rate. Many manufacturers just won't supply Costco, in fact in the US there has never been a good quality reliable manufacturer supplying Costco Hot Tubs so this leaves them dealing with the low end of the industry and that's never a good place to start from.
  4. The fourth reason that Costco Hot Tub reviews are so bad is that there is a total lack of available information, product support and assistance. These specialty products need timely information so that minor issues don't blow up into big issues, but that kind of support costs money and the companies supplying Costco Hot Tubs can't afford to offer that support because, again the pricing is so out of whack with where it needs to be to even supply a good product, never mind offering reliable backup and support. It's doomed to fail before it even gets out the door!
  5. The final reason why Costco Hot Tub reviews rates these tubs so low is because they use gimmicky tricks to make you think the hot tub is high end. Tricks like using lots of jets and pumps because customers always think more is better. But in the hot tub industry the little jets are cheap, like $10 and do little or nothing for real muscle massage, so they will put 70 of them in a hot tub and the consumer goes WOW! That's way more jets than the expensive tub I was looking at but the expensive tub has 40 of the $50 high end therapy massage jets so the $700 jet package on the Costco Hot Tub might look great on paper but the $2000 jet package on a high end therapy massage spa is going to be a much better performing hot tub.

Hot Tub University uses a proprietary algorithm that takes into account a myriad of things... from the weight and thickness of the shell, to various manufacturing techniques, to the quality of parts and it's unbiased in so much as it just crunches the numbers and gives a rating that takes into account known failure rates on various parts. Like leaks based on how the jet attaches to the shell or how the plumbing attaches to the jets, right down to the type and amount of resin used on the shell. When we run Costco Hot Tubs through our evaluator, they come out exactly where we expect them to! At for that price of spa… right near the bottom!

In our opinion, Costco Hot Tub reviews are right, these are not good prices on great hot tubs, they are just regular pricing on cheap hot tubs.

So let's look at what the Hot Tub University’s evaluator says about Costco Hot Tubs when we run the numbers… But before I even do,all you have to do is look at the basic numbers to know it's a low end unit. After all, a 91” 90 jet 3 pump spa that weighs in at only 800lbs (according to Strong whom I had to call for the information) means its has very little resin on the shell, it's a thin cradle supported low end tub, hell we have tested similar sized tubs with 40 jets and 2 pumps that weighed damn near 1400lbs! That means they are using almost twice as much fiberglass and resin on the shell constitution and that's worth thousands of dollars all by itself! But let's see what the Hot Tub University’s evaluator says

Evolution Spas Monarch 90 Jet, 7-Person Spa

Shell Rating
4.1
Plumbing Rating
4.0
Equipment Rating
8.1
Construction Rating
4.9
Components Rating
6.0
Efficiency Rating
5.5
Reliability Rating
7.0

Overall Rating
4.5

Shell

The shell is constructed from fiberglass which means that it has an acrylic surface backed by fiberglass. While this is the preferred way to build a hot tub shell, the amount of fiberglass and how it is applied is key to the strength of the tub. In the case of this particular tub, the shell strength calculation indicates a weak shell which is of major concern and shell issues such as cracks or delamination are more likely in the future.

Plumbing

This hot tub has 2 pumps and a circ pump and 90 jets. More importantly there is a total of 10hp driving those jets. To effectively move water with that number and size of jets the pumps will work extremely hard and shorten the life of the pumps. With the plumbing lines not clamped this tub runs a much higher risk of leaking than a hot tub with properly clamped plumbing joints. This issue is magnified by the number of jets since every jet becomes a potential leak point. The hot tub does not have foam insulation which means that all the plumbing is free floating without any support. This can increase the chances of leaks due to vibrations from the pumps.

Equipment

The pumps in this hot tub will run very hot since the power of the pumps is not sufficient for the number and size of jets and premature failure of the pumps is likely. The tub uses Waterways jets which are among the best in the industry and are readily available from many sources so if you have any jets break in the future, they will be inexpensive and readily available.

Construction

One of the primary components that affect the construction of any hot tub is the shell itself.The shell of the tub is, obviously, what holds the water but it also forms the entire structure of the tub. The shell is constructed from rolled fiberglass which is our preferred method of shell construction but with a shell rating below 5, this is a weak shell and there is significant danger of issues in the future. The shell is cradle-supported which means there are supports under the shell to help carry the load of the water. The better quality shells are self-supporting and require no additional support so this indicates weakness in the shell. The frame of a hot tub should never be used for shell support and, in a properly constructed hot tub, the frame is only there to provide balance and a place to mount the equipment and hold the skirting in place.A wood frame is the most common method of frame construction and supports the equipment and skirting very well

Components

The shell of this tub is cradle supported which means the shell is reinforced with support blocks. The need for these blocks speaks clearly to the strength of the shell and any shell that is self-supporting (as all hot tub shells should be) and should not have any additional support. The Gecko control system in this tub is not a terrible option but it is not at the same level as something like a Balboa. In addition, future repair costs will be higher because any pack will require heater replacement in 5-7 years and replacement heaters for Gecko packs are very expensive.

Efficiency

The pumps in this hot tub are slightly underpowered for the amount of water they need to push. This means that they will not operate at 100% efficiency but should be adequate for the hot tub. Mylar blanket insulation has been touted as space-age and exciting new technology but the truth is, mylar blankets are great for reflecting heat from a point source (such as the sun) but do little to trap heat inside an enclosure because the heat in the hot tub is distributed so heat can escape very easily. This is the least effective method of insulating a hot tub and is done because it is far less expensive to the manufacturer than proper foam insulation.

Reliability and Repairability

The rating for the pumps in this hot tub are well below what would be required to move the amount of water in the plumbing system of this particular tub. This means they will run very hot and fail far more quickly than properly rated pumps. Perimeter insulation systems and blanket insulation traps heat inside the cabinet of a hot tub. The main spa control pack and the pumps will be running in an environment that is much hotter than is ideal so both pump and pack life will be shortened. The jets in this hot tub are reliable and readily available from many sources so if any jets break in the future, they will be inexpensive and readily available. This is critical for out of warranty maintenance costs. The Gecko control system in this tub is not a terrible option but it is not at the same level as something like a Balboa. In addition, future repair costs will be higher because any pack will require heater replacement in 5-7 years and replacement heaters for Gecko packs are very expensive.


Share this post:

Comments